“How Wide Is God’s Mercy, How Deep is God’s Love?” (Philippians 2:5-11)
October 5th, 2008
Rev. Dr. David Andersen, English Language Sabbatical Interim Pastor
When I was young I remember waking up one morning and walking down the hallway of our upstairs bedrooms and looking in the bedrooms of my family and seeing no one and hearing no one downstairs. A flush of panic overtook me. I thought to myself, what if Christ had come in the night and I have been left behind? If you have ever had such a thought you know it does not stem from a sense of God’s Love but God’s wrath. Yet, every Sunday I sat in a church that proclaimed Jesus Christ as personal Savior, and I had made profession of faith and been baptized.
So, where did this fear come from? It came in the restrictive way in which salvation had been preached and taught in my church. Salvation was for the few, the very few who made profession of faith in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, but even with such a profession the fear lingered, because how did you know you were believing in just the right way that would save you. Instead of being taught the wideness of God’s mercy and the depth of God’s love, I was taught the limits of God’s mercy and the restrictivism of God’s Love.
On the other hand, salvation can be taught in such a way that everybody is saved and nobody is left out. It is a very generous concept but in the end can lead to a relativism in which nothing matters, everything is relative and no theological statement or doctrine is any more true than any other and it really doesn’t matter what you believe because in the end everybody’s belief is as valid as anyone else’s. So, which is it, the many or the few?
There are these two extremes of restrictivism on one hand and universalism on the other hand, and you are left to choose between one or the other. I refuse to make that choice. I can’t make that choice, but I can tell that over the years my sense of God’s mercy and my awareness of God’s love has grown wider and wider, embracing more and more, and the way this has happened is by an increasingly greater appreciation for the work of the Holy Spirit in the work of salvation.
This is where my journey has led me and I hope by sharing it with you it opens up discussion and causes you to reflect more seriously on how you would answer, who are saved, the many or the few? This morning I don’t mean to sound autocratic. I am not trying to say, I am right and you had better listen to me and get all the right answers. Instead, what I am asking for is an attitude within the church that nurtures a spirit that allows for openness and freedom where we can truly become exploratory in our faith and allow for the open presence of God’s Spirit in the very act of discussion. The message this morning is prompted from a request by the Chicago Baptist that we focus this morning on the Holy Spirit in recognition of a national conference of American Baptist on the Holy Spirit that was held at our church this weekend.
I begin on an airplane. Sharon and I were flying into Athens, Greece, and the plane dipped down and was practically on the runway when the pilot for some reason revved up the engines and took the 747 back up into the sky. My heart raced and I held my breath, but we ultimately landed safely. Even before we landed, however, when I had gotten over my initial fear, what came into my mind as we had such a close view of the city from the air was the thought, can it possibly be that all these people below me, these millions of people I could almost see we were so close to the ground, can it be that all these people are doomed to an eternity of hell unless here on earth they came to a saving knowledge of Jesus Christ and professed him as Savior?
I couldn’t answer. The thought that so many people would be lost seemed too horrendous to me. I think the reason the thought entered my mind in the first place was that we were entering the land of the Apostle Paul’s missionary work. If, however, this was the way it was, that only the few who made a personal decision would be saved, I wasn’t able to comprehend it. To me, such a theology inevitably meant that hell was gong to be a much, much bigger place than heaven ever could be. Most people are not Christian and never have been. This means that the work of Christ on the cross, for all the agony of it was only for a minority of people.
Is this fair to the redemptive, cost giving part of salvation? God gave His son, let Him die on a cross, yet, in a sense, in the end, you can say the devil won because even today if all souls professed Christ as Savior, you still have all the souls of history who never even heard of Him. Do we dare say, Christ died only for the minority of people, or do we profess, Christ died for the world?
Second, it is not just the numbers but the duration of time we are given to decide that haunts me and always has. Is it really Love that gives a person 60 or 80 years on earth to decide a fate that seals that person’s doom for all eternity? Can we say that a God who created the world out of Love and sent His Son to redeem that world then forgets for all eternity more than half of humanity when they die and never again utters their name because they didn’t utter His Son’s name in the brief moment of time that was theirs on earth?
I know if one of my children was lost to me, there would never be a day in my life that I would not carry in my heart the pain of that love. I cannot conceive that God could ever enjoy the fellowship of His children at the Messianic Banquet in heaven, knowing that while these children are celebrating most of the children He once loved are now doomed to the every lasting torment of separation from Him. It seems to me that if this was true, it would be in the end that God’s wrath trumps God’s Love.
The thing is in spite of what we are taught and in spite of what we say we believe, we find ways to ease the pain of it when it comes to thoughts of our own family and those we love who might have died without ever in anyway giving any indication to us of being a professing Christian. Something in us cannot give into the thought that someone we loved is right now spending eternity in hell. In our heart we profess a hope that somehow that loved one died knowing the Lord. The alternative is too painful. We have to somehow believe that God’s mercy is somehow deeper.
I think that hope within us is warranted and I will tell you why. It is because though Christ has chosen as His primary witness to the world, His Church, and this behooves us to be a witnessing evangelistic people, God is not limited to the Church. There is a third person of the Trinity, the Holy Spirit, and the Spirit is not bound, and everywhere on this globe and in every human heart the Holy Spirit is working to bring each person to an awareness of God and the Love God has for that person.
Sometimes the evangelistic role of the Church is not so much to take God’s love to the world, but to help people identify where God has been working in their lives long before the Church got there or long before they knew the name of Christ.
My daughter told me about a time in her life when she sat on a park bench at a bus terminal. All the money she had in the world was in her purse. A homeless person came and sat beside her. She was living in another city, but her apartment hade been destroyed by fire and she had lost her job and she didn’t know what to do. The homeless person started to talk to her and she told him her story. She said to him, “I don’t know whether to use this money to run away or if I should go home and start over. The homeless person said to her, “Honey, if I were you I would get on that bus and go home.” My daughter told me this story, which I never knew, the day of her wedding.
That homeless person helped to save her life and all across the world, that same Holy Spirit who worked through that homeless person is working to bring people Home.
I believe there is no other name under heaven whereby we are saved than the name of Jesus Christ. My theology is restrictive in that manner. But I also believe as stated by the Apostle Paul, “That at the name of Jesus every knee will bow and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord.”
I haven’t put all the pieces together, but both my mind and heart tell me that in the end hell will be a lot less empty and heaven a lot fuller than any of us have ever imagined.
Zechariah 14:9 says, “The Lord will become king over all the earth; on that day the Lord will be one and his name one.”
Clark Pinnock, a Baptist theologian says, “God is Person, and people can receive the gift of his love without knowing exactly who the giver is or how much it cost. This is the way that holy pagans like Enoch, Melchizdek and Job were saved.” (p.1980)
Zwingli, the great Protestant reformer said, “There has not lived a single good man, there has not been a single pious heart or believing soul from the beginning of the world to the end, which you will not see in the presence of God.” (p.198)
Wofhart Pannenberg, the theologian, has written, “Others…without even knowing it and without knowing Jesus, honored Jesus and his teaching by the way they treated the needy and will participate in the kingdom of God.”
But, alas, it is Jesus, who most influences both my heart and mind. When I look at Jesus, I see God, and the God I see is a God filled with Love, a God all loving, a God who is Love. That love is not bound by my theology. That love is not bound by my human restrictive ways of sharing my own love. That love will find a way.
In the book of Isaiah there is an image of the end time which for him is expressed through a vision of a mountain and this is what he sees and it is with this vision I end. It is the same vision I read at Rev. Reyes installation:
“On this mountain the Lord of hosts will make for all peoples a feast of rich food, a feast of well aged wines…
And he will destroy on this mountain the shroud that is cast over all peoples, the sheet that is spread over all nations; he will swallow up death forever.
Then the Lord God will wipe away the tears from all face, and the disgrace of his people he will take away from all the earth, for the Lord has spoken.” (Is. 25:6-8)
How can this be? I don’t know, except to say, as I see when I look upon the face of Jesus and see God. “‘Tis mercy all.”


